Biden Announcement on Trump Climate Change Rules for Aviation- not well met by 100 environmental groups

future of green aviation
Share this article: FacebooktwitterlinkedinFacebooktwitterlinkedin

Administration adopts the Trump path to Global CO aviation standards through ICAO

Green Groups lambasts the position with their facts

While the record is replete with good green actions by Aviation

The debate over aviation’s contribution to Climate Change is, at best, contentious. Below is an article announcing the Biden Administration’s to stay with the Trump Administration’s regulations on greenhouse gas emissions from aircraft. The White House further indicated that this was not an end point and that it will aggressively pursue green goals for US aircraft operations at ICAO’s sessions on CORSIA. The statement also cited its U.S. Aviation Climate Action Plan which makes it clear that the administration and industry support those critical milestones. The person, who will lead the US delegation to set these standards, is former Captain SullenbergerCapt. Sullenberger

 

The environmental groups (100 signatories to the joint letter[1]) responded with the sort of overblown invective which assures that the discussion will not reach a productive atmosphere”:

 

Biofuels are not proven to be carbon neutral or sustainable. Some jet biofuels cause more greenhouse gas emissions than fossil fuels. They can also result in increased emissions of nitrogen oxide, an air pollutant associated with respiratory illnesses including asthma.

“Call it greenwashing or ‘greenwishing’ but voluntary biofuel pledges won’t save us from climate catastrophe,” said Liz Jones, an attorney at the Center for Biological Diversity’s Climate Law Institute. “Despite being by far the largest airplane polluter in the world, the United States has stalled any meaningful aircraft emissions rules for more than a decade. Enforceable carbon pollution cuts are better than all the aspirational ambitions in the world, and they need to start now.”

“Rather than overturn Trump’s hollow, corporate-friendly regulations for aircraft emissions, Biden is exacerbating the problem by propping up dirty, false solutions like biofuel,” said Hallie Templeton, legal director for Friends of the Earth. “This administration must swiftly and meaningfully regulate harmful aircraft emissions, finally doing the right thing for the climate and communities.”

“Aircraft are a large and growing source of harmful emissions and yet remain largely unregulated,” said Sarah Burt, deputy managing attorney at Earthjustice. “If we’re to prevent devastating warming of our planet and protect the public from harmful air pollution, we have to move towards zero-emissions aviation. The EPA must set us on that path with a strong rule that significantly and immediately reduces carbon emissions from this sector.”

This really does not bode well for a consensus.

greenpeace

 

 

 

 

 


Biden administration signals it will keep Trump-era aircraft emissions rule

 

Biden at Glasgow

BY ZACK BUDRYK – 11/16/21 11:01 AM EST 28

The Biden administration in a court filing Monday night indicated it will continue Trump-era regulations on greenhouse gas emissions from aircraft.

In a statement, the EPA defended the move and said it understood the need for further action to reduce emissions from aviation.

Biden 2021 Plan “That is why the U.S. will press for ambitious new international CO2 standards at the upcoming round of ICAO negotiations, why in September the Biden Administration announced a series of actions aimed at boosting the development of sustainable aviation fuel, and why earlier this month the Biden Administration released the U.S. Aviation Climate Action Plan at COP26,” the statement said.

 

The agency added that it would explore possible other actions it can take under the authority of the Clean Air Act, which is independent of the ICAO standards.

The Trump administration rule, which would implement standards from the International Civil Aviation Organization (ICAO’s CORSIA), has been sharply criticized by environmental advocates, who note it would do little to meaningfully reduce aviation emissions. The agency itself wrote in 2020 that it was “not projecting emission reductions associated with today’s proposed GHG regulations.”

The Center for Biological Diversity (CBD), one of several environmental groups that filed a separate lawsuit over the rule, had harsh words for the Biden administration’s decision.CBD

[MORE: Consortium demands Biden administration cut airplane pollution through standards and not SAF ]

“White House officials had barely deplaned from their trip to the U.N. climate conference before the administration announced it won’t do anything to cut airplanes’ greenhouse pollution,” Liz Jones, an attorney at CBD, said in a statement. “The Biden administration has taken climate hypocrisy and delay to new heights. After being directed to review the useless Trump rule as part of a strategy to confront the climate crisis, the EPA twiddled its thumbs for nine months before deciding it would rather defend a do-nothing rule than set any meaningful limits on aircraft emissions.”

A CBD spokesperson confirmed to The Hill it will continue the lawsuit, adding that both parties should submit a briefing proposal no later than Dec. 6.

Commercial air travel is a significant source of U.S. greenhouse gas emissions, comprising about 3 percent of national emissions in 2018, according to EPA data…”

Aviation's Climate Impact


SOME USEFUL INFORMATION

As climate concerns threaten air travel, aviation industry banks on technology solutions

Can Hydrogen Save Aviation’s Fuel Challenges? It’s Got a Way to Go.

Airports have halved emissions between 2010-2019

U.S. Airlines Announce 3-Billion-Gallon Sustainable Aviation Fuel Production Goal

A4A' green commit

A4A hydrogen deploymentDallas Fort Worth Begins SAF Delivery

Recycles Waste Feedstock From Airport Vendors

Yeager Airport looking into operations of electric infrastructure

Tracking Biden’s
environmental actions
WaPo Biden dashboard

CUTTING AVIATION POLLUTIONWWF logo

by

Understanding aviation’s real environmental cost

How Innovation Is Helping Airlines Cut Carbon Emissions

Helping decarbonize industry with carbon capture and storage

ATAG green plan

IATA commitment

 

Flight Plan: How The Aviation & Aerospace Sector Can Address Sustainability

GREENING Of Aviation: Altitude, Innovation And Capture

Greening Of Aviation—In Multiple Dimensions

Winglets Are Saving 5 Billion Gallons A Year—Get The Message Out About Aviation’s Greening Accomplishments!

                        Biden Administration :SAF Is Coming-A Good Green Goal

Innovative Aviation Designs Hydrogen Powerplant To Include A Robust Distribution System

H2 To 0 Carbon Emissions- Tech Update

PASS IT ON: GREEN AIRLINE NEWS

Alaska Airlines’ Engines Are Stoked With Wood & That’s GREEN

Think Globally, Act Locally—Private Sector Aviation Green Initiatives Are Delivering Benefits NOW

The Battle Over The “Facts” Of Aviation’s Environmental Record, And The Power Of Media

 

 

[1] ??? 1. 350 Bay Area Action 2. 350 Eugene 3. 350 Mass Metro North Node 4. 350 Seattle 5. 350 Triangle 6. 350 Hawaii 7. Advocates for the Environment 8. Animals Are Sentient Beings, Inc. 9. Animas Valley Institute 10. Aviation-Impacted Communities Alliance 11. Bergen County Green Party 12. BOS Fair Skies 13. Breast Cancer Action 14. Businesses for a Livable Climate 15. Call to Action Colorado 16. Carrizo Comecrudo Tribe of Texas 17. Cascadia Wildlands 18. Catholic Network US 19. Center for Biological Diversity 20. Christian Council of Delmarva 21. Christians For The Mountains 22. Clean Energy Action 23. Climate Hawks Vote 24. CO Businesses for a Livable Climate 25. Concerned Citizens of Palo Alto 26. Conservation Congress 27. Coordinador De Pueblos y Organizaciones Del Oriente Del Estado De Mexico En Defensa De La Tierra, El Agua y Su Cultura (CPPOEM) 28. Earth Action, Inc. 29. Earthjustice 30. Eco-Eating 31. Empower our Future 32. Endangered Habitats League 33. Endangered Species Coalition 34. Environmental Protection Information Center 35. Faithful America 36. Feminists in Action Los Angeles 37. Flight Free USA 38. Food & Water Watch 39. Fresnans against Fracking 40. Friends of the Earth 41. Global Anti-Aerotropolis Movement (GAAM) 42. Great Egg Harbor Watershed Association 43. Green Education and Legal Fund 44. Green New Now 45. GreenLatinos 46. Institute for Policy Studies Climate Policy Program 47. International Marine Mammal Project of Earth Island Institute 48. Jewish Climate Action Network 49. KyotoUSA 50. LA Forward Action Climate Justice 51. Logan Aircraft Noise Working Group, Boston, Massachusetts 52. Milwaukee Riverkeeper 53. Mira’s Garden 54. No Jets Santa Monica Airport 55. North Alabama Peace Network 56. North American Climate, Conservation and Environment (NACCE) 57. Nuclear Information and Resource Service 58. Occupy Bergen County 59. Oil Change International 60. Oregon Aviation Watch 61. OVEC-Ohio Valley Environmental Coalition 62. Pelican Media 63. Phil Berrigan Memorial Chapter Veterans For Peace 64. Plane Sense 4 Long Island 65. PSR Colorado 66. Public Lands Project 67. Quiet Skies Coalition 68. Quiet Skies Puget Sound 69. Rachel Carson Council 70. Rainforest Action Network 71. Rainforest Relief 72. RapidShift Network 73. Resource Renewal Institute 74. Rocky Mountain Neighborhood Conservancy 75. San Francisco Bay Physicians for Social Responsibility 76. San Francisco Baykeeper 77. Santa Cruz Climate Action Network 78. Save Our Skies East Bay 79. Save The Frogs! 80. Sisters of St. Dominic of Blauvelt, New York 81. SoCal 350 Climate Action 82. Social Eco Education (SEE-LA) 83. South Asian Fund For Education, Scholarship and Training INC (SAFEST) 84. Sparc Power 85. Spirit of the Sun 86. Strathmore Village Civic Association 87. Sunflower Alliance 88. Sunrise Movement Los Angeles 89. Sunrise Movement 90. Surfrider Foundation Los Angeles Chapter 91. Syracuse Cultural Workers 92. The Climate Center 93. The River Project 94. Transition Sebastopol 95. Turtle Island Restoration Network 96. Unitarian Universalists for a Just Economic Community 97. Unite North Metro Denver 98. Wasatch Clean Air Coalition 99. WATCH, INC 100. WESPAC Foundation, Inc ???

 

multiple layers of aviation greening



 

Share this article: FacebooktwitterlinkedinFacebooktwitterlinkedin

1 Comment on "Biden Announcement on Trump Climate Change Rules for Aviation- not well met by 100 environmental groups"

  1. JE Murdock III | November 17, 2021 at 1:32 pm | Reply

    #80
    Sisters of Blauvelt
    https://www.opblauvelt.org/???no stated interest in or knowledge about the environment and aviation specifically. Wonder how many others were included to get to a “magic” 100?

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.